See what your budget buys →
Home › For employers › Guides
Alternatives

Alternatives to group health insurance for a small business in New York

You have five realistic options besides a traditional group plan: a QSEHRA or ICHRA (you reimburse employees for their own insurance), a level-funded plan, a health-sharing ministry, a high-deductible plan paired with direct primary care, or direct primary care and dental memberships on their own. Only the last two put an actual doctor in front of your employees for a fixed price. Memberships cost $135 a month per person for a Long Island doctor and $325 a year for a dentist, with no underwriting, no minimum participation and no renewal.

The options side by side

OptionEmployer cost / employeeWhat the employee gets
Traditional group plan~$657/mo + renewalsInsurance with a $2,631 deductible
QSEHRA / ICHRAWhatever you set (often $300–$600/mo)Cash toward a plan they buy themselves
Level-funded planSimilar to group, with a possible refundInsurance, needs 10+ enrollees usually
Health-sharing ministry$200–$500/moNot insurance; no guarantee of payment
HDHP + direct primary careHDHP premium + $135/moHospital coverage plus a doctor on call
DPC + dental memberships only$135/mo + $325/yrA local doctor and dentist, no deductible

How memberships work

1You set a budget

Pick a max per employee for a doctor and a dentist. The page shows which local practices fit.

2Each employee picks

They choose their own doctor and dentist from that list. No network cards, no claims.

3One invoice a month

Itemized per person. You pay what each person actually picked. Start or stop any month.

Set a budget and see your team's options →
Or call (516) 927-2771 for free guidance. A real person, no sales pitch.

Common questions

Which option is cheapest?

Memberships alone, by a wide margin. They don't replace hospital coverage, so many owners pair them with a catastrophic or high-deductible plan and still come out far below a full group plan.

Can I combine a QSEHRA with memberships?

Yes. A QSEHRA reimburses insurance premiums; memberships are a separate benefit you pay directly. Ask your accountant how to document each.

Is a membership a 'health plan' under the ACA?

No, and that's deliberate. It's a direct agreement between the employee and the practice. Companies under 50 employees have no ACA employer mandate anyway.

How fast can I set this up?

About eight minutes on upsurance.co/employers. Employees are usually enrolled within the week.

Related guides